The Discrimination Devil


In early September, 2018, President Donald Trump nominated Brett Kavanaugh for a seat on the Supreme Court, to replace the elderly Justice Anthony Kennedy, who was retiring. Justice Kennedy positioned himself as an independent, deciding on each case by his own legal compass, even siding occasionally with the liberal justices, Sotomayor, Kagan, Bader-Ginsburg, and Breyer.

Neither Trump nor most leading Republicans made any effort to conceal their nominee's conservative positions. The appearance, at any rate, of a "biased" justice antagonized Democrats in Congress, which caused a tumult during Cavanaugh's congressional hearing. Liberals, Black leaders, and Feminists worked hard to discredit him. The American public shivered with every step of the process--discrimination against the minorities, discrimination against the whites! How will all this play out? 

Left-wing activists feared that subsequent decisions by the Supreme Court would marginalize or eliminate important initiatives like the so-called "Affirmative Action," a near-euphemistic term for ethnic preference--in this case Blacks and Latinos over Whites and Asians.

Democrat fears increased as two more elderly Justices retired or died, givingTrump the opportunity to push through two more nominees, Gorsuch and Barrett. Along with Justices Thomas, Alito, and Chief-Justice Roberts, they gave the conservatives an unassailable majority, which infuriated the left-wingers.

The lack of a unified agenda and the antagonism between the two political camps makes governing a matter of favoring one side over the other, giving America a disabled or skizoid functionality; but until the two sides take a long-term view of the situation and figure out that we can't keep going like this, the nation has to soldier on, ravaged by internal divisions--a quick ticket to capitulation to someone--the Chinese or the Russians, or one faction of its own people arrayed against the other. I repeat, we can't keep going like this. We have to spin off new nations.

The German newspaper Frankfurter Allgemeine published an interesting article in its September 9, 2018, issue titled "When the State Discriminates"--in German, "Wenn der Staat diskriminiert." This post derives much of its inspiration from the article. As the title suggests, Affirmative Action says something important about our society--how much political  power controls its functions, even its system of justice. Once upon a time, institutions discriminated--Blacks, Jews, Italians, Protestants, Catholics, Baptists, Episcopalians, even atheists. Discrimination cuts so many ways, reflecting personal preferences rather than a political agenda. With Affirmative Action, the government says, "Only we get to discriminate."

It interferes with a basic drive in human nature, the desire to win. Those cushy New England prep schools work the dog out of a person. The trustees who oversee the schools want nothing more than to produce more leading scientists, literary giants, entrepreneurs, and presidential cabinet members--all of them alumni! So they want the best. Jewish legal scholars like Merrick Garland, Alan Dershowitz, and Ruth Bader-Ginsburg have supported Affirmative Action, as the means to correct past injustice and pull the nation away from a "meritocracy," promotion guided by personal achievement; but I doubt they wanted ethnic preferences when they were themselves students. Can you imagine them agreeing to graduate far down the class-ranking so that poor students of other races could get ahead? But shouldn't they do that if they apply the egalitarian standard across the board? Obviously not! So why demand that White or Asian students make that kind of pointless sacrifice?


Merrick Garland


Alan Dershowitz, right; Claus von Bülow, left


Ruth Bader-Ginsburg

People pursue politics guided by only primitive instinct. Do whatever you can get away with! We've seen it play out time and time again. Political rivalry employs fierce, brutal tactics, as brutal as any gladiator sport, or even a street brawl. Hardly anything brings out the animal in people like politics. It is the main reason our planet Earth has so few democracies. The political animal rears its ugly head in this country, now. . . . America's days are numbered. We must avoid the fate of other nations and divide the country, so that both political camps can govern a nation. Resuscitate democracy within governable units, dictated by the philosophies of the parties. 


Blog

January 21, 2022
Founding Father Credo: James Madison

Founding Father Credo: John Adams

When I think of the important persons who helped found our nation, who did the fighting to free the nation from the British, who studied the lessons of history in order to build a hugely successful land of opportunity, and undergird it with first-rate foundational documents, I do not think right away of fFrancis Scott Key. ...


January 17, 2022
Founding Father Credo: George Washington

Lloyd Bowers

Email